Selenium: Why the Soil, Not the Food, Decides How Much You Get

22 October 2026
MIT

Selenium is a trace mineral your body needs in tiny amounts (55 micrograms a day for adults); it builds enzymes that protect cells and activate thyroid hormone. What sets it apart from most nutrients is that the amount in a food is not decided by the food itself but by the soil it grew in: a single Brazil nut can give you a fraction of your daily need or several times it, depending on where it came from.


That is why food tables alone cannot tell you how much selenium you are getting, and why "taking more" is not a safe way to protect yourself. In this Bakery 8 guide we explain why the soil writes the number before it reaches your plate, how much you really need, when extra becomes harmful, and what the trials say about supplements, diabetes and the thyroid.


🌱 What Is Selenium and Why Does Your Body Need It?


Selenium is measured in micrograms (thousandths of a milligram). It does not act alone; it is built into a family of proteins called selenoproteins, including:


Glutathione peroxidases: enzymes that help clear oxidative by-products inside cells.


Deiodinases: enzymes that convert thyroid hormone from its storage form (T4) to its active form (T3).


The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements (ODS) notes that selenium deficiency can worsen the effects of iodine deficiency when the two occur together and may raise the risk of congenital hypothyroidism, which is why selenium is so closely tied to thyroid health.


🗺️ Why Doesn't the Type of Food Decide How Much Selenium You Get?


This is the idea the whole article turns on. For most nutrients, knowing the name of a food tells you roughly what is in it: oranges have vitamin C, milk has calcium. Selenium is different, because plants do not make it; they absorb it from the soil. Grow wheat, nuts or vegetables in selenium-poor soil and they will be selenium-poor, whatever they are called.


According to NIH ODS, selenium in plant foods varies widely by location because it depends on how much selenium the soil holds, its chemical form, soil pH and organic matter. Animal foods such as fish, meat and eggs are more consistent, because animals regulate selenium in their tissues and formulated feeds are fairly uniform.


Brazil Nuts: The Clearest Example


Brazil nuts are always called the richest source of selenium, and NIH ODS estimates an average of 68 to 91 micrograms per nut, more than a full day's need. But that average hides huge swings. A 2021 article in Frontiers in Nutrition summarised Brazilian studies measuring nuts from different states: in one, selenium ranged from 5 to 71.5 micrograms per gram; in another, from 0.5 to 98 micrograms per gram. The authors note that nuts from some regions can exceed daily needs while nuts from others provide under 10% of them, which makes a single "safe number of nuts" hard to set.


Finland: Adding Selenium to the Soil Itself


The clearest proof that soil sets the number comes from Finland, where soils are naturally low in selenium. In 1984 the country began adding selenium to agricultural fertilisers. The Finnish monitoring programme report for 2000–2001 shows blood levels tracking the policy: after the fertiliser dose was cut in 1990, serum selenium was about 1.10 µmol/L in 1999; after the dose was raised from 6 to 10 mg per kg of fertiliser in 1998, it climbed back to about 1.40 µmol/L. Average intake reached about 80 micrograms a day in 2001. Finns did not change what they ate; the soil changed, and so did their blood.


China: When Soil Is Very Poor


In selenium-poor parts of China, a heart-muscle disease called Keshan disease appeared, mainly in women of childbearing age and young children. NIH ODS reports that adults there got 10 micrograms a day or less, while at least 20 micrograms is needed for protection, and a 2018 meta-analysis of 41 studies found supplements cut the risk of the disease by 86% in those areas. There, the problem was poor soil and the fix simply restored the minimum.


⚖️ How Much Selenium Do You Need, and When Is It Too Much?


Figures from NIH ODS for adults:


Daily requirement (RDA): 55 micrograms for men and women aged 14 and over.


Pregnancy: 60 micrograms. Breastfeeding: 70 micrograms.


US upper limit (UL): 400 micrograms a day.


European upper limit (EFSA, 2023): 255 micrograms a day.


Notice the gap between the two bodies. In 2023 the European Food Safety Authority reviewed the evidence, chose hair loss as an early sign of excess, and used data from the large SELECT trial, where adverse effects appeared at around 330 micrograms a day, to set a lower adult limit of 255 micrograms (including during pregnancy and breastfeeding). When two trustworthy bodies disagree, we at Bakery 8 lean towards the more cautious figure.


The Gap Between "Enough" and "Too Much" Is Short


The daily need is 55 micrograms; the European limit is 255. That is less than a five-fold margin, narrow compared with many nutrients. According to the NIH ODS table, one ounce of Brazil nuts (6 to 8 nuts) may contain about 544 micrograms, more than twice the European limit in a single handful. That is why EFSA explicitly named two exceptions to "adults are unlikely to exceed the limit": regular users of high-dose supplements and regular eaters of Brazil nuts.


What Does Too Much Selenium Look Like?


Chronic excess is called selenosis. NIH ODS lists hair loss and brittle or lost nails as the most common signs, often preceded by garlic-like breath and a metallic taste, along with rash, nausea, diarrhoea, fatigue and irritability. In 2008, 201 people in the United States had severe reactions after taking a liquid supplement that turned out to contain 200 times the selenium stated on its label, a reminder that a label does not always guarantee what is in the bottle.


💊 Do Selenium Supplements Protect Against Cancer or Diabetes?


Selenium supplements became popular in the 1980s and 1990s in the hope of preventing cancer, and the idea was tested in large trials. We will not retell the whole antioxidant story here; instead, we read the trials through the soil lens: who benefited, who was harmed, and why?


The SELECT trial: 35,533 men in the US, Canada and Puerto Rico took 200 micrograms a day. It was stopped after 5.5 years with no reduction in prostate cancer. In a later analysis, the risk of high-grade prostate cancer rose in men whose toenail selenium was already high at the start, and the researchers advised men over 55 to avoid doses above recommended intakes (as summarised by NIH ODS).


The NPC trial and diabetes: in a secondary analysis of a randomised, placebo-controlled trial published in the Annals of Internal Medicine in 2007, researchers followed 1,202 people without diabetes for an average of 7.7 years. Type 2 diabetes developed in 58 people taking 200 micrograms of selenium a day versus 39 on placebo, and risk was highest in those with the highest baseline blood selenium. The lead author cautioned that the finding "should be considered cautiously" and needs confirmation in larger trials, as diabetes was a self-reported secondary outcome.


This is where the soil returns. In China, supplements rescued people eating 10 micrograms a day; in these two trials, the striking pattern is that people who started high were the most likely to be harmed. The starting point set by your soil and diet changes what the same dose means. So the right question is not "is selenium good for you?" but "where are you starting from?"


🦋 Selenium and the Thyroid: Does It Help Hashimoto's?


Because of selenium's link to thyroid enzymes, it is widely promoted for autoimmune thyroiditis (Hashimoto's). What does the evidence say?


Cochrane review (2013): 4 trials, 463 participants. Selenium lowered thyroid antibodies (TPOAb) in some studies, but the authors called the clinical relevance "unclear" and concluded the evidence does not support selenium as a treatment for Hashimoto's. This is the 2013 version of the review.


A newer review summarised by NIH ODS: 9 trials, 679 participants, found no effect on TSH, thyroid ultrasound appearance or quality of life, and its authors likewise concluded the evidence does not support supplementation for this condition.


In pregnancy: according to the NIH ODS summary, the American Thyroid Association (2017) made a weak recommendation against selenium for pregnant women with thyroid antibodies.


A lower antibody number is not the same as a patient feeling or doing better. If you have thyroid disease, your doctor should decide based on your results.


🇸🇦 What Do We Know About Selenium in Saudi Arabia?


We looked for recent population-level Saudi data and found no published national survey of blood selenium, or of selenium in local soils and crops. That in itself matters: we do not know precisely where people here start from.


The closest study we found, published in Molecules in 2009, included 140 men attending outpatient clinics at two hospitals in Jeddah. The researchers estimated that about 86% had dietary selenium intakes below the average requirement, described the selenium and iodine status of the sample as "low", and found selenium associated with thyroid function. But this is a small hospital sample from one city, more than 15 years old; it is a signal worth following, not a rate for the population.


The picture is further complicated by how much of our food is imported from countries with very different soils. So it is not safe to assume you are low or adequate without testing, especially before starting a supplement.


⚠️ Who Should Be Careful?


According to NIH ODS, people at higher risk of low selenium include:


People on haemodialysis: dialysis removes some selenium, and poor appetite and dietary restrictions lower intake.


People living with HIV: low levels are common.


Strict vegans in selenium-poor regions: the more stable animal sources are missing.


On the other side, anyone taking a selenium-containing supplement (including multivitamins and "hair and nails" or "immunity" products), anyone eating Brazil nuts daily, and anyone doing both should watch for excess.


See your doctor promptly if you notice the following, especially while taking a supplement:


  • Unusual hair loss, or brittle or discoloured nails.
  • Garlic-like breath without eating garlic, or a persistent metallic taste.
  • Repeated nausea or diarrhoea with fatigue or irritability.
  • A new skin rash or tingling in the hands or feet.


This article is for education only and does not replace medical advice. Do not start a selenium supplement or stop thyroid treatment without talking to your doctor, particularly during pregnancy or with kidney or thyroid disease.


✅ Practical Tips


1. Lean on stable animal sources: per NIH ODS, 3 ounces (85 g) of tuna provides about 92 micrograms, canned sardines about 45, shrimp about 42, beef about 37, chicken breast about 22, and one large egg about 15. A varied diet with these foods usually covers your needs.


2. Treat Brazil nuts like a supplement, not a snack: one nut can meet or exceed your day, and a handful can pass the upper limit. If you enjoy them, have one or two, and not every day.


3. Read the label of every supplement you take: add up selenium from your multivitamin, hair supplement and immunity product, and compare the total with the 255-microgram European limit.


4. Don't start a supplement because of a vague symptom: fatigue and hair loss have many causes, and excess selenium itself causes hair loss.


5. Ask your doctor before pregnancy: the need rises only slightly, to 60 micrograms, which food usually covers. Don't add a separate supplement on top of prenatal vitamins without advice. Planning a pregnancy? Our guide on folic acid timing covers the nutrient that matters most before conception.


🍞 Where Does Bakery 8 Fit In?


To be clear: we have not measured the selenium content of our products, so we do not claim any of them is a selenium source, and you should not count them as one. We also know that in some countries wheat is an important selenium source because it is grown in selenium-rich soil (NIH ODS notes that New Zealand's intakes rose when it imported high-selenium wheat). If you have cut back on conventional bread for health reasons, the answer is not a supplement but making sure fish, eggs, meat and chicken appear in your week.


Our role is simpler: to make a low-carb, gluten-free or sugar-free routine easier to keep, so your plate stays varied and balanced. Pair boiled eggs or tuna with Bakery 8's gluten-free, sugar-free bread such as samoli or cloud bread, serve our crackers alongside sardines and salad, or start the morning with keto granola and yoghurt. Balance comes from the whole plate, not one product.


❓ Selenium FAQ


How many Brazil nuts can I eat a day?


There is no single safe number for everyone, because selenium per nut depends on the soil it grew in; the average is 68 to 91 micrograms, but some nuts carry far more. One or two now and then is plenty, while a daily handful can exceed the European upper limit of 255 micrograms.


Do I need a selenium supplement?


Most people eating a varied diet with fish, eggs and meat do not. A supplement may be prescribed for specific situations such as dialysis or a deficiency confirmed by testing, and that is your doctor's call. Large trials found no preventive benefit in people with adequate levels, and showed possible signals of harm.


Does selenium raise the risk of diabetes?


In a randomised trial published in 2007, type 2 diabetes developed in 58 people taking 200 micrograms a day versus 39 on placebo. The researchers urged caution because it was a secondary outcome, but it is one more reason not to take selenium without a clear need.


Does selenium treat Hashimoto's?


Systematic reviews do not support it. Selenium lowered thyroid antibodies in some studies, but it did not clearly improve TSH or quality of life. Whether to use it is a decision for your endocrinologist based on your results, not something to add on your own.


What are the signs of too much selenium?


The best known are hair loss and brittle nails, often preceded by garlic-like breath and a metallic taste, with nausea, diarrhoea, fatigue or a rash. If these appear while you are taking a supplement, stop it and see your doctor.


🧭 The Bottom Line


Selenium is not a "more is better" mineral, and you cannot tell how much you are getting just from a food's name. Soil writes the number: in Finland fertiliser raised it, in China it decided who fell ill, and in a Brazil nut it makes one nut too little or too much. The safest route is a varied diet with fish, eggs and meat, caution with supplements and Brazil nuts, and your doctor's advice before any supplement. And if you want your bread to fit a balanced, sugar-free and gluten-free plate, Bakery 8's range from Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, is made to make that easier.


📚 References


  1. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Selenium: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals. Updated September 4, 2025.
  2. EFSA Panel on Nutrition, Novel Foods and Food Allergens (NDA). Scientific opinion on the tolerable upper intake level for selenium. EFSA Journal. 2023;21(1):7704.
  3. Eurola M, Alfthan G, Aro A, Ekholm P, Hietaniemi V, Rainio H, Rankanen R, Venäläinen E-R. Results of the Finnish selenium monitoring program 2000–2001. Agrifood Research Reports 36. MTT Agrifood Research Finland; 2003.
  4. Dias JPV, Sobrinho PSC, Pimenta AM, Hermsdorff HHM, Bressan J, Nobre LN. Dietary Selenium Intake and Type-2 Diabetes: A Cross-Sectional Population-Based Study on CUME Project. Frontiers in Nutrition. 2021;8 (Brazil-nut variation figures as summarized from earlier studies).
  5. Stranges S, et al. Effects of long-term selenium supplementation on the incidence of type 2 diabetes: a randomized trial. Annals of Internal Medicine. 2007 (via University at Buffalo news release, July 2007).
  6. van Zuuren EJ, Albusta AY, Fedorowicz Z, Carter B, Pijl H. Selenium supplementation for Hashimoto's thyroiditis. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2013, Issue 6: CD010223.
  7. Alissa EM, Ahmed WH, Al-ama N, Ferns GA. Selenium Status and Cardiovascular Risk Profile in Healthy Adult Saudi Males. Molecules. 2009;14(1):141–159.


Related keywords: selenium, selenium benefits, Brazil nuts selenium, selenium deficiency, selenium toxicity, selenium and thyroid, selenium supplements, foods high in selenium.