Diabetes and Osteoporosis: Why a Normal Bone Scan Can Mislead, and What Protects Bone

30 October 2026
MIT
Diabetes and Osteoporosis: Why a Normal Bone Scan Can Mislead, and What Protects Bone

Diabetes and osteoporosis are linked in a way many people miss: type 1 diabetes multiplies the risk of a hip fracture several times over, and type 2 diabetes raises it too, even though the bone density scan of many people with type 2 looks "normal" or even better than average. The reason is that diabetes damages bone quality more than bone quantity, and the standard scan only measures quantity.


This article explains why a reassuring density number can sit on top of weaker bone, how doctors adjust the scan for people with diabetes, which diabetes medicines deserve a conversation with your doctor, and what actually protects bone day to day. It is educational and does not replace advice from your own doctor.


🦴 What is the link between diabetes and osteoporosis?


A large meta-analysis by the Danish researcher Peter Vestergaard, published in Osteoporosis International in 2007, pooled dozens of studies and found a picture that looks contradictory at first:


  • Type 1 diabetes: hip fracture risk about 6.9 times higher than in people without diabetes, with below-average bone density (hip Z-score around −0.37).
  • Type 2 diabetes: hip fracture risk about 38% higher, even though bone density is above average (hip Z-score around +0.27).


In the study's own words, hip fracture risk is increased in both types, whereas bone density is increased in type 2 and decreased in type 1. Someone with type 2 diabetes can carry "denser" bone on paper and still break it more often in real life.


That is the heart of the matter: density is not quality. Picture two brick walls with the same number of bricks, one laid with good mortar and one with crumbly mortar. Count only the bricks and they look identical. Hit them, and one gives way first.


🔬 Why is bone in diabetes weaker than its number?


Bone is not inert mineral. It is living tissue: a protein scaffold (collagen) with minerals laid on top, constantly broken down and rebuilt. The Bone and Diabetes Working Group of the International Osteoporosis Foundation (IOF), in its 2018 reference paper, summarises several mechanisms that make diabetic bone weaker than its density suggests.


1. Sugar sticks to collagen


Chronically high glucose speeds the formation of advanced glycation end products (AGEs), chemical cross-links between sugar and proteins. As they build up in bone collagen, the scaffold becomes stiffer and less able to absorb impact. Levels of some AGEs, such as pentosidine, have been linked to higher fracture risk and lower bone material strength.


2. Bone renewal slows down


In studies that took bone biopsies, the rate of new bone formation in people with diabetes was roughly 70–80% lower, and blood markers of bone turnover were also reduced. Bone that does not renew efficiently accumulates microscopic cracks that never get repaired.


3. Small blood vessels


Thinner, more porous outer (cortical) bone has been seen mainly in people with microvascular complications such as kidney, eye or nerve disease. The same tiny vessels that feed the eye and the kidney also feed bone.


4. Falls: the other half of the story


A fracture needs weak bone and an impact. Diabetes raises the odds of the impact in several ways: reduced feeling in the feet from neuropathy, poorer vision from retinopathy, episodes of low blood sugar, and blood pressure that drops on standing. The New York State Department of Health's leaflet on diabetes and bones notes that in type 2 diabetes fracture risk may be higher even at the same bone mass, and lists vision changes and nerve damage in the feet as causes of falls.


📉 Why can a DEXA bone density scan mislead if you have diabetes?


A DEXA scan gives you a "T-score", comparing your bone density with that of a healthy young adult. The familiar rule is that −2.5 or below means osteoporosis, and between −1 and −2.5 means low bone mass (osteopenia). The problem is that these cut-offs were built on people who do not carry the "quality defect" that diabetes adds.


In a study published in JAMA in 2011, Ann Schwartz and colleagues pooled three long-running US cohorts covering 9,449 women and 7,436 men. They found that, for a given T-score and age, adults with diabetes had a higher risk of fracture than those without it, and that the widely used FRAX fracture-risk calculator underestimated their risk.


How do doctors correct the reading?


The 2018 IOF working group paper suggests practical adjustments for people with type 2 diabetes:


  • Lower the T-score by 0.5 before entering it into FRAX. The paper notes that having diabetes is roughly equivalent to adding ten years of age or reducing the T-score by half a standard deviation.
  • Tick "rheumatoid arthritis = yes" in the calculator as a stand-in, because FRAX has no box for type 2 diabetes.
  • Add the trabecular bone score (TBS), an extra reading taken from the same DEXA image that reflects some of the bone's internal structure rather than density alone.


Most importantly, the paper suggests that a T-score of −2.0 (instead of −2.5) could be an appropriate threshold for considering drug treatment in diabetes, as could a loss of about 5% or more of bone density over two years. The US National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (NIDDK) makes the same point in a 2022 interview with Ann Schwartz: in diabetes, DEXA "tends to underestimate fracture risk".


The American Diabetes Association (ADA) added dedicated bone-health recommendations to its Standards of Care from the 2024 edition, endorsed by the American Society for Bone and Mineral Research (ASBMR). Risk factors highlighted in those recommendations, as summarised in a 2025 review in Osteoporosis International, include diabetes for more than ten years, HbA1c above 8%, nerve, eye or kidney complications, and very low body weight.


💊 Do diabetes medications affect bones?


Some do. That is not a reason to stop anything on your own; it is a reason to know what is worth asking about.


Medicines linked to higher fracture risk


  • Thiazolidinediones (such as pioglitazone): the approved prescribing information reports that in the PROactive trial fractures occurred in 5.1% of women on pioglitazone versus 2.5% on placebo over about 34.5 months, with no clear increase in men, mostly in the lower leg and forearm. NIDDK states that this class doubles fracture risk in women.
  • Canagliflozin: in 2015 the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) added a fracture warning to its label, after fractures appeared as early as 12 weeks into treatment in some trials, and a two-year trial in 714 older adults showed decreases in bone density at the hip and lower spine. That warning is specific to this drug, not the whole class (see our article on SGLT2 inhibitors).
  • Insulin and sulfonylureas: their link with fractures is mostly indirect, through low blood sugar leading to falls, as the IOF paper notes.


What do experts prefer for people at high fracture risk?


For a patient at high fracture risk, the IOF paper leans towards medicines with a low risk of hypoglycaemia, such as metformin and incretin-based drugs, and prefers empagliflozin or dapagliflozin over canagliflozin within that class. The final decision belongs to your doctor, who has to balance bone against heart, kidneys, weight and glucose together.


Do osteoporosis drugs work in diabetes?


In a later analysis of the well-known FIT trial, having diabetes did not change the effect of alendronate on bone density gain versus placebo, and Danish registry data found a similar fracture benefit in people who kept taking their treatment. In fairness, though, no randomised trial has yet been designed specifically to test fracture prevention in people with diabetes.


🇸🇦 Osteoporosis in Saudi Arabia: why it matters here


The International Osteoporosis Foundation estimates that about 23% of Saudi women aged 50–70 have osteoporosis, a figure based on 2008 data, so it is old and due for an update. The Saudi Osteoporosis Society's 2023 guideline update reports annual hip fracture rates of about 77.5 per 100,000 women and 56.8 per 100,000 men. With diabetes common in the Kingdom, the two risks meet in a large group of people.


Local factors also deserve attention: little real sun exposure despite abundant sunshine, and inactive daily routines, both of which affect vitamin D and bone.


✅ How to protect your bones if you have diabetes


The good news is that most of what protects bone also protects the rest of the body. These are the main points from the IOF paper and public health leaflets:


  1. Ask for a fracture-risk assessment: especially if you have had diabetes for more than ten years, have complications, or have broken a bone in a minor fall. Ask your doctor: was my scan read with the diabetes adjustment?
  2. Avoid hypos: every low is a chance to fall. In older adults, a less tight glucose target is sometimes safer, and that is a decision your doctor makes with you.
  3. Weight-bearing exercise: walking, stairs and other activities where you carry your own weight stimulate bone, while strength and balance work builds the muscle that protects you from falls.
  4. Enough protein: the IOF paper stresses adequate protein and exercise to protect muscle and bone during weight loss, because losing weight can cost bone if both are neglected.
  5. Calcium and vitamin D: the paper cites about 1,000 mg of calcium a day, preferably from food, and about 800 IU of vitamin D a day, or more if needed to reach a blood level of 30 ng/mL. Do not start high-dose supplements without your doctor.
  6. No smoking: it harms bone and blood vessels alike.
  7. A fall-proof home: good night lighting, no slippery rugs, grab bars in the bathroom, proper footwear, and regular foot and eye checks.
  8. Steady long-term glucose control: AGE build-up is tied to chronically high glucose, so good, stable control is part of protecting bone quality.


⚠️ When to see a doctor without delay


  • A fracture from a fall from standing height or less, even a wrist.
  • Sudden back pain without an obvious injury, noticeable height loss, or a new stoop.
  • Repeated falls, or dizziness on standing.
  • Frequent hypos, or hypos you no longer feel.
  • Starting or continuing one of the medicines above while you have fracture risk factors.


Note: this content is for awareness only and does not diagnose or treat. Do not stop any medicine or start a supplement without talking to your doctor.


🥗 What about low-carb eating and bones?


A fair question, and the honest answer is that the evidence is limited. In a two-year non-randomised trial published in Frontiers in Endocrinology in 2019, 262 people with type 2 diabetes followed a programme based on nutritional ketosis. Spine bone density was unchanged, and the researchers concluded there was no adverse effect on bone health. But the study did not measure fractures, and the programme had several components.


So we will not tell you that any eating pattern "strengthens bones". What can be said is that better glucose control is good for bone as part of a bigger picture, and that any weight-loss diet needs enough protein, movement and calcium sources so that bone does not pay the price.


🍞 Where does Bakery 8 fit in?


Let us be clear: no bread improves your bone quality, and none of our products is a substitute for a scan, a medicine or a supplement your doctor prescribes. Bakery 8 / مخبز ثمانية products in Riyadh are not calcium supplements, and if anyone tells you otherwise about any product, be wary.


What we offer is simpler: sugar-free, low-carb options that help people who are working on their glucose keep bread and breakfast on the table:



❓ Frequently asked questions about diabetes and osteoporosis


Are people with diabetes more likely to get osteoporosis?


People with type 1 diabetes often have lower bone density and a much higher hip fracture risk. In type 2, density is usually normal or higher, yet hip fracture risk is about 38% higher according to Vestergaard's 2007 meta-analysis, because the problem lies in bone quality and falls, not density alone.


Why can a bone density scan be normal in diabetes and the bone still break?


Because a DEXA scan measures how much mineral the bone holds, not the quality of its structure. Diabetes alters collagen through glycation, slows bone renewal and harms small blood vessels, so bone absorbs impact less well. That is why doctors may lower the T-score by 0.5 when using the FRAX calculator.


What T-score calls for treatment in someone with diabetes?


The 2018 International Osteoporosis Foundation working group paper suggests −2.0 as an appropriate threshold for considering treatment in diabetes, rather than the usual −2.5, along with a loss of about 5% of bone density over two years. The final decision depends on your doctor's full assessment of your risk factors.


Can diabetes medications cause bone loss or fractures?


Some are linked to more fractures, such as pioglitazone in women and canagliflozin, which received an FDA label warning in 2015. Insulin and sulfonylureas are linked to fractures mostly through hypos and falls. Never stop a medicine on your own; discuss it with your doctor if you have fracture risk factors.


Does exercise prevent fractures in diabetes?


Nothing prevents fractures completely, but weight-bearing exercise stimulates bone, and strength and balance training build muscle and reduce falls, which are half the cause of fractures. Start gradually, and check with your doctor first if you have neuropathy, retinopathy or frequent hypos.


🌿 The bottom line


In diabetes, a normal density number does not necessarily mean strong bone. Ask your doctor for a fracture-risk assessment that accounts for diabetes, cut down on hypos, keep moving, get enough protein, calcium and vitamin D, and make your home fall-proof. And if you are looking for bread and breakfast that help you manage glucose day by day, browse Bakery 8's range at your own pace and choose what fits the plan you have agreed with your doctor.


📚 References


  1. Vestergaard P. Discrepancies in bone mineral density and fracture risk in patients with type 1 and type 2 diabetes — a meta-analysis. Osteoporosis International. 2007;18(4):427–444.
  2. Ferrari SL, Abrahamsen B, Napoli N, et al. (IOF Bone and Diabetes Working Group). Diagnosis and management of bone fragility in diabetes: an emerging challenge. Osteoporosis International. 2018;29:2585–2596.
  3. Schwartz AV, et al. JAMA. 2011;305(21):2184–2192 (via ScienceDaily summary of the press release, 31 May 2011).
  4. NIDDK, US National Institutes of Health. Can Diabetes Lead to Bone Problems? Diabetes Discoveries & Practice, 2022.
  5. US FDA. Drug Safety Communication: FDA revises label of diabetes drug canagliflozin (Invokana, Invokamet) to include updates on bone fracture risk and new information on decreased bone mineral density. 2015.
  6. Pioglitazone Prescribing Information, section 5.6 (fractures).
  7. American Diabetes Association. Standards of Care in Diabetes — 2024: Summary of Revisions (bone health recommendations 4.9–4.14 added).
  8. Starup-Linde J, et al. Osteoporosis International. 2025 (review of bone health recommendations in diabetes).
  9. Al-Saleh Y, et al. (Saudi Osteoporosis Society guideline updates). Archives of Osteoporosis. 2023;18:75; and International Osteoporosis Foundation, Key statistics for Middle East and Africa.
  10. Athinarayanan SJ, et al. Frontiers in Endocrinology. 2019 (two-year non-randomised nutritional ketosis trial, bone health outcomes).


Related keywords: diabetes and osteoporosis, bone density in diabetes, DEXA scan, diabetes fracture risk, diabetes medications and bones, bone health, falls in older adults.